Why move from MP3 to M4A
iPhones play MP3 perfectly well, so this conversion is not about making the files playable. People do it for other reasons. Some want their whole library in the format Apple uses for its own store. Some use apps or devices that work better with M4A, such as certain podcast tools and Android voice apps. And some need M4A as a step towards something else, like an audiobook chapter file or an iPhone ringtone, which uses the same container under a different name.
How quality is affected
M4A usually holds AAC audio, which is a lossy codec. Converting from MP3 means decoding one lossy format and encoding another, so there is always a small generation loss. AAC is efficient, but that efficiency cannot recover what MP3 already discarded. Follow these rules and the difference will not be audible:
- Never choose a bitrate much lower than the MP3. For a 128 kbps MP3, use 160 or 192 kbps AAC.
- For a 320 kbps MP3, 256 kbps AAC is enough. That is the bitrate of iTunes Store downloads.
- Keep the original sample rate and channels.
Sizes compared
| Bitrate | Size per minute (MP3 or M4A) |
|---|---|
| 128 kbps | 0.96 MB |
| 192 kbps | 1.44 MB |
| 256 kbps | 1.92 MB |
Bitrate decides the size, not the format, so an M4A at the same bitrate is the same size as the MP3.
Tags and getting files onto an iPhone
Title, artist, album and track number are copied from the MP3 into the M4A. The embedded cover art is copied too, so albums look right in Apple Music. To put the files on an iPhone, add them to the Music app on a Mac (or iTunes on Windows) and sync, or save them in the Files app. If your real goal is a ringtone, go straight to MP3 to M4R or the iPhone ringtone maker. Need the opposite direction later? Use M4A to MP3.