Reasons to convert MP3 to FLAC
FLAC is lossless, which makes some people expect that converting an MP3 into it will raise the quality. It will not, and it is important to say that clearly. There are still good practical reasons for this conversion:
- Your music player, server or DJ software is configured for FLAC only.
- You want every file in a library to share one format and one tag system.
- You plan to edit the audio several times and do not want a new MP3 encode after each edit.
- A music platform or teacher asks for FLAC files.
Why the quality stays the same
MP3 encoding removes sound permanently, mostly high frequencies and quiet details masked by louder ones. FLAC then stores whatever is left, perfectly. Think of it like scanning a photocopy at high resolution: the scan is exact, but it is still a scan of a photocopy. A 128 kbps MP3 usually has nothing above about 16 kHz, and the FLAC made from it will show the same sharp cut-off in a spectrum analyzer. This is also how experienced listeners detect fake lossless files on the internet.
File size
FLAC compresses the decoded audio without loss, but decoded MP3 audio does not shrink as well as you might hope. Typical results:
| Format | Size per minute |
|---|---|
| MP3, 192 kbps | 1.4 MB |
| FLAC made from that MP3 | 4 to 7 MB |
| WAV, 16-bit 44.1 kHz | 10.6 MB |
So FLAC is roughly half the size of WAV, but three to five times larger than the MP3 it came from.
Settings and tags
Use 16-bit. A 24-bit FLAC made from an MP3 holds no extra detail and takes more space. Keep the original sample rate. Title, artist, album, year and track number move from ID3 tags into FLAC Vorbis comments, so the files stay organised in players like foobar2000 or Plex. The embedded cover art is copied as well.
If you have the original CD or a WAV master, convert that instead with WAV to FLAC. That gives you a real lossless copy.