The codec behind the ringtone
Every M4R ringtone already contains AAC audio. The difference between an M4R and a raw .aac file is the packaging. M4R wraps the audio in an MPEG-4 container with an index, tags and sometimes artwork. A raw AAC file is a simple stream of audio frames with small headers (called ADTS), without a container.
When you need raw AAC
- Some car head units, set-top boxes and portable players list .aac but not .m4a or .m4r.
- Some broadcasting, streaming and VoIP tools accept AAC streams only.
- Some programs that join or loop short sounds work with .aac files more easily.
- Certain intercom, alarm and doorbell systems use AAC sound files for their tones.
If none of these apply and you just want a normal audio file, M4R to M4A or M4R to MP3 are more convenient, because they keep tags and open everywhere.
Settings and quality
The converter decodes the AAC inside the ringtone and encodes a fresh AAC stream. This allows you to change the bitrate, sample rate or channels, at the cost of a tiny loss from re-encoding. Keep the bitrate at or above the source, usually 192 or 256 kbps. For a sound that will play through a small speaker, 128 kbps mono is enough and makes the file half the size.
A 30-second tone at 192 kbps comes to about 0.7 MB. Raw AAC has no fields for title or artist, so name the file clearly.
A note on length
Raw AAC files have no index, so some players show the wrong length or cannot jump to a point in the file. With a ringtone of 40 seconds or less, that is rarely a problem. If you plan to combine several tones into one longer clip, do it first in Merge and then convert the result.
Old tones from the iTunes Store may have copy protection and cannot be converted. Tones made with GarageBand, ringtone apps or the iPhone ringtone maker work without issues.