Same audio, different label
An M4R ringtone and an M4A song are built the same way: AAC audio inside an MPEG-4 container. The extension decides how Apple software treats the file. With .m4r, Finder and iTunes send it to the Tones list. With .m4a, the Music app, GarageBand, iMovie and most other programs see it as a regular audio file.
Rename or convert?
Often, simply renaming the file from .m4r to .m4a is enough, and it keeps the audio exactly as it is. Try that first if all you need is to open the tone in another app.
Converting M4R to M4A here makes sense when:
- you want a different bitrate, for example a smaller file for sharing or a fixed bitrate for an app;
- you want to switch the tone to mono or change the sample rate;
- renaming did not help because an app checks the file more strictly;
- you have many tones and want them all in one consistent format.
Because conversion decodes and re-encodes the AAC, it adds a very small loss. Choose a bitrate equal to or above the source to keep it inaudible; 256 kbps is a safe choice.
Using the M4A
Once it is an M4A, you can add the tone to your music library and play it like a song, put it into a GarageBand project to remix it, or use it as a sound in a Keynote presentation or iMovie video. Tags from the ringtone, if any, are copied across.
Making changes and going back
If you want to change the ringtone itself, for example make it longer, add a fade or start at another point, it is easier to work with the original song. The iPhone ringtone maker creates a new M4R from any track. To edit the tone you have, convert it to M4A or WAV and open it in the audio editor. When you are done, M4A to M4R turns it back into a ringtone, as long as it stays within 40 seconds.
Tones bought from the iTunes Store long ago may be protected and will not convert; recent purchases and tones you made yourself work normally.