Lossless at home, MP3 on the go
FLAC is the format of choice for CD rips, band download stores and high-resolution releases. It keeps every sample, but a single album can take 300 MB to well over 1 GB, and plenty of devices still do not play FLAC: many car stereos, older iPhones, simple MP3 players and some smart speakers. The common solution is to keep the FLAC files as a master library and convert FLAC to MP3 for everything portable.
Which bitrate to choose
Because FLAC is lossless, this is a clean first-generation encode, and you can choose purely by how much space you have:
| MP3 bitrate | A 45-minute album | Listening experience |
|---|---|---|
| 320 kbps | about 108 MB | indistinguishable from FLAC for nearly everyone |
| 256 kbps | about 86 MB | excellent |
| 192 kbps | about 65 MB | very good; fine for phones and cars |
| 128 kbps | about 43 MB | acceptable; cymbals and reverb lose some detail |
The same album as 16-bit FLAC is typically 250 to 350 MB, and as 24-bit, 96 kHz FLAC often 1 GB or more.
Hi-res files and tags
MP3 is limited to 48 kHz and works with roughly 16-bit resolution. A 24-bit, 96 or 192 kHz FLAC is converted to a supported rate automatically. Ultrasonic content above 20 kHz is dropped, but you could not hear it anyway, so a hi-res source does not produce a better MP3 than a CD-quality one.
FLAC stores tags as Vorbis comments, and these are copied into ID3 tags: title, artist, album, album artist, track number, year and genre. That keeps your converted albums sorted correctly on a phone or in a car. Embedded cover art is copied too.
One big FLAC with a CUE sheet
Some CD rips are a single FLAC file for the whole album plus a .cue file listing the tracks. The converter turns it into one long MP3. To get separate songs, split the MP3 at the track start times with the split tool. If some albums in your collection sound much louder than others after conversion, normalize can even them out. For Apple devices, FLAC to M4A is a good alternative that sounds slightly better at the same size.